Egypt’s revolution searching for its path
Arab Revolutions
The new elected parliament in Egypt has the necessary task of changing the failed neoliberal model of a police state governed by a family for the benefits of foreign powers, capital and a comprador class — one that lives not off development but from different kinds of rent — into a democratic welfare state. It is a great task that should be accomplished with tact and with the support and comprehension of all economic actors,including the private sector,so as to avoid chaos or paralysis.
Social justice shouldn’t mean only ensuring the necessary better revenues for all, as this alone would result, among other things, in inflation. It should be simultaneously inciting better and larger production. The first urgent necessity is to attempt to ensure food security in the country. The agriculture and alimentary industry should be intensively and extensively developed. To avoid inflation, aid should be better directed to the producer, so as to incite him to improve his production and not only the product. The same thing applies to other sectors, including construction, transport, energy, health, family, education, jobs, training, the unemployed and the elderly.Aid to the person gives state administration the possibility of distributing revenues according to income, of selecting the products that should be incited to be produced, and to redistribute revenues and augment production without creating inflation and black markets.Deputies should urge the government, specialists and economists to put forward plans so that all families have a revenue, and at the same time that jobs can be created, production increased, monopolies and sources of black markets and corruption suppressed, competitiveness enhanced, the environment protected, administration and public services reformed and the budget balanced by reducing the deficit and public debts through improved commerce and real development. All Arab countries have a high potential for development. They have an abundance of factors of production that could be mobilised individually and collectively. It suffices to be mobilised rationally for the benefit of all, not only the few.
Social justice programmes cannot be achieved but through legitimate, democratic, stable institutions of the state. The base of any democracy is a free individual, woman and man, and a free citizen, woman and man. International human rights standards and treaties should be ratified and applied.
The legislature should ensure that state institutions apply these standards. The state is the state of all Egyptians. Public interest is imperative. Nothing in its laws, structures, procedures, and the behaviour of its agents, should serve — or show any form of discrimination against — any particular individual, group, or ideology, even if initiated by the government in the name of the majority. Special attention should be directed to the physical and moral integrity and dignity of citizens, especially women, minorities and children, to be guaranteed and applied by all state institutions.
Arab regimes are late in the process of democratisation in the world. One of the reasons is the role played by the big powers in supporting non-democratic regimes during their Cold War: for the West, dictatorial comprador regimes; for the East, one-party regimes. While democracy is a system by which society directs its public affairs, the end of the Cold War didn’t end the culture that accompanied it. The pro-Westerns limited their criticism of dictatorial regimes and demand for change by beginning a shy criticism of regimes based on the necessity of individual liberties in individual life without criticising the neoliberal globalised structure and the comprador class enforcing and profiting from it, while the leftists continue to see and think of revolution as a putsch of an avant-garde group establishing the dictatorship of workers and poor peasants as a way to suppress the State: their model is The State and the Revolution of Lenin. American culture is a liberal ideology of less state; the leftists adopted the ideology of one party that leads the state and society. Although world political culture abandoned both neoliberalism and putschism, these two cultures continue to have their avant-gardism in the Arab world.
In Egypt, this is expressed by two positions. The first is the insistence on transferring power to some liberals before any election or constitution. The second is to consider elections as a non-event. Between these, there are reasonable positions held by varied political actors. The first is the position supporting the drafting of a constitution first. Since de Tocqueville’s On Democracy in America, political science knows the danger of a state without recognised values or a constitution that limits the risk of the dictatorship of the majority vote. The constitution is a social pact to live and manage public affairs peacefully together. In a democratic state, non-respect of the constitution in decisions is considered a putsch, even if voted by a majority. The second legitimate position is that it is the elected assembly that should draft the constitution. This position is legitimate because a constitution is not given to the people but written by the people. Although there was the suspicion that religious parties wanted to impose a religious state, agreement on the Al-Azhar Document lifted this suspicion. The third is the position of the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF), expressed on 23 July, in the constitutional declaration, and in the roadmap for transferring power to an elected president.
The problem with the avant-gardists is that they take their legitimacy from themselves while the only legitimacy in a democratic state is the legitimacy borne from elections. Many things limit even this legitimacy. The first is the constitution, which should contain all kind of limitations to guarantee equality among citizens and prevent the dictatorship of the majority. The legitimacy of the legislative branch is also limited by time. The legislature should be re-elected periodically. Electing a deputy is not giving them the absolute power to decide everything in the life of electors.
It is only delegating to them while keeping the right to pull from them their powers, in the next elections and even before. The third limitation comes from the impossibility for the legislative and executive branches to direct social life in its detail. From this springs the role of the media, expressions of public opinion such as demonstrations, strikes, art, expert research, publications and statements, universities and research centres, freetrade unions, local elections and institutions, and specialised non-governmental associations. The fourth limitation comes from the several other elected bodies: the senate, the president and local administration. Each has its prerogative and legitimacy. The fifth limitation is the institutions of the state and its cultural heritage, because laws even voted will not be enforced efficiently without their acceptance and the possibility that the institutions concerned have faith in them. The opposite is a crisis in the work of the administration that should be addressed.
One problem in the thinking of the avant-gardists is the idea that the revolution is one act to install on the top of the state people that issue revolutionary laws. These laws would have no effect if not supported by the people. Society and the state apparatus and the country’s geopolitical relations make this thinking subjective, impossible to realise and in some aspects dangerous, even if it springs from a real thirst for liberty and progressive aspirations. In Egypt, in their slogans against SCAF, the avant-gardists didn’t present a workable alternative. All society appreciates their role in sparking the January 25 Revolution, but their slogans are seen as harmful, as the elections proved. Happily after one year, most of the youth have abandoned putschism and return to affirming, in group work and outlook, the importance of peaceful change, preparing already for future elections, after the success of the recent elections. No one can deny them this right and appreciated role, or attack it.
In a democratic state no group has a special political privilege. But in all states, democratic or not, the armed forces have a special functioning different from other institutions of the state. In all Third World countries, as in some capitalist countries, the military draft was not only to ensure capacity to face war, but also to develop strategic research and studies, industrial and civil infrastructure, train workers, to administer the public sector and to guarantee enforcement of the law and a civil state. It is to the constitution to decide, calmly and scientifically, the way the army works as an institution of the state, without harming national security and the national economy. In this domain we can say that as Egypt is targeted as a power, despite the absence of a state of war, the army should be prepared to defend national security in all domains of the state. Egypt is not living in a peaceful environment so as to reveal its military plans and budget publicly, although these plans and budget should be inspected and ratified by the deputies of the people.
A heavy responsibility lies on the shoulders of political groups, the elected of the people, and the government of Egypt. The more rapidly and transparently they apply necessary changes, the more the future of Egypt will shine. We are sure the love of the people of Egypt for their country and their confidence in its capacity will make this heavy task easier.
Abdul Ilah Albayaty is an Iraqi political analyst. Hana Al Bayaty is an author and political activist. Dr Ian Douglas is a specialist in the geopolitics of the Arab region and has taught at universities in the US, UK, Egypt and Palestine.
Pingback: order dapoxetine online india()
Pingback: goodrx albuterol hfa()
Pingback: how to make hydroxychloroquine()
Pingback: what companies manufacture hydroxychloroquine()
Pingback: hydroxychloroquine prescribing information()
Pingback: hydroxychloroquine for head lice oral()
Pingback: get hydroxychloroquine online()
Pingback: ivermectil street price per pill()
Pingback: increase priligy effectiveness()
Pingback: plaquenil e coli()
Pingback: price stromectol 6mg()
Pingback: stromectol 6mg capsules for sale()
Pingback: liquid ivermectin for sale walmart()
Pingback: ivermectin wonder drug()
Pingback: stromectol 375()
Pingback: generic ivermectin online()
Pingback: social signals()
Pingback: נערות ליווי()
Pingback: How can I make my wife happy at night levitra for sale online?()
Pingback: Can erectile dysfunction be a symptom of hypoparathyroidism in males levitra online purchase?()
Pingback: Medications - Unraveling the Complexity of Autoimmune Diseases buy Azithromycin?()
Pingback: Medications and Mental Health Empowerment - Breaking Chains, Inspiring Growth ivermectin pyrantel?()
Pingback: Medications and Fitness - Maximizing Workouts, Achieving Peak Performance scaly leg mite treatment ivermectin?()
Pingback: Medications and Peripheral Neuropathy - Managing Nerve Pain priligy?()
Pingback: Elder Abuse Awareness - Protecting Vulnerable Seniors vidalista professional 20 mg?()
Pingback: The Future of Healthcare Lies in Personalized Medication priligy buy on usa?()
Pingback: dapoxetine generic?()
Pingback: Medications and Cancer Prevention - Guarding Against the Unseen Enemy viagra pills near me?()
Pingback: Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction - Finding Inner Peace cheap fildena 100?()
Pingback: Medications and Liver Health - Nurturing Vital Organ Function kamagra 100mg tablets?()
Pingback: Qu'est-ce qu'il ne faut pas manger avant de faire l'amour female viagra?()
Pingback: Can bacterial diseases be transmitted through contact with contaminated surfaces in cruise ships metronidazole flagyl 500 mg tablet for dogs?()
Pingback: What bacteria causes sepsis ivermectin human?()
Pingback: Can antibiotics prevent infection in patients with a weakened immune system Azithromycin to treat chlamydia?()
Pingback: Can lack of sleep cause high blood pressure where can you buy ivermectin()
Pingback: What should a woman do to make a man happy vidalista 40 online()
Pingback: What are the 3 types of asthma breathing spray ventolin 100()
Pingback: How long can you have heart disease and not know lasix dose()
Pingback: viagra 150 mg for men how it works()
Pingback: pictures of generic viagra pills()
Pingback: flagyl 250 posologia()
Pingback: How do I keep my prostate healthy??()
Pingback: How to get a hard on at 60??()
Pingback: How do you make a baby??()
Pingback: dapoxetine and cialis - How do you fix an erectile dysfunction?()
Pingback: hydroxychlor 200 mg()
Pingback: poxet 60()
Pingback: vidalista 60 mg on amazon()
Pingback: buy amoxicillin cvs()
Pingback: buy dapoxetine()
Pingback: androgel dosing()
Pingback: vidalista 60 mg centurion laboritories()
Pingback: order furosemide pills()
Pingback: cheap sildenafil 50mg()
Pingback: vilitra 20 reviews()
Pingback: vilitra 20mg pills()
Pingback: sildenafil citrate IP tablets 20 mg()
Pingback: priligy tablets()
Pingback: proair digihaler()
Pingback: vilitra 20()
Pingback: Generic clomid without a prescription()
Pingback: What is a dangerously low heart rate when sleeping hydroxychloroquine 200 mg?()
Pingback: Anonymous()
Pingback: ivermectin buy()
Pingback: Cenforce 100 review()
Pingback: kamagra pharmacy malaysia()
Pingback: sildenafil and dapoxetine tablets()
Pingback: hcqs 200()
Pingback: nolvadex price()
Pingback: web md vidalista()
Pingback: Cenforce uk()
Pingback: cheap vidalista 20mg india()
Pingback: hcq generic name()
Pingback: fildena ct()
Pingback: generic vidalista()
Pingback: vidalista nedir()
Pingback: clomiphene 50mg for male()
Pingback: over the counter clomid substitute()
Pingback: clomiphene Citrate 50mg men()
Pingback: clomid 50mg for male side effects()
Pingback: cialis with dapoxetine()
Pingback: dapoxetine 60 mg sildenafil 100mg()
Pingback: cheap kamagra()
Pingback: vidalista kaina()
Pingback: vidalista 10mg()
Pingback: advair()
Pingback: fildena 120mg()
Pingback: order priligy online()
Pingback: cenforce 50 side effects()
Pingback: Cenforce 200()
Pingback: Cenforce()
Pingback: buy dapoxetine()
Pingback: Sildenafil 100 online()
Pingback: buy kamagra 100()
Pingback: vidalista 20mg()
Pingback: albuterol()
Pingback: ventolin inhaler()
Pingback: fildena 25 reviews()
Pingback: clomiphene 50mg tablets()
Pingback: buy advair()
Pingback: bystolic()
Pingback: fildena online()
Pingback: buy super p force online()
Pingback: kamagra jelly()
Pingback: vidalista tadalafil 60 mg()
Pingback: seretide diskus 500()
Pingback: buy cenforce online()
Pingback: order levitra professional oo()
Pingback: ciprodex hc()
Pingback: cenforce 100()
Pingback: buy loniten online()
Pingback: ventolin inhaler()
Pingback: ivecop 12 tablet uses()
Pingback: kamagra jelly pack()
Pingback: ivecop 12 tablet()
Pingback: iverheal12()
Pingback: vermact 12 dosage()
Pingback: iverwon 12()
Pingback: vidalista 20 mg review()
Pingback: iverwon 12 tablet uses()
Pingback: levitra coupons()
Pingback: tadalista que es()
Pingback: proairhfa()
Pingback: buy cenforce 100()
Pingback: priligy 60()
Pingback: priligy 30()
Pingback: priligy review()
Pingback: vidalista 40 side effects()