Tahrir 12 months down
Much has changed, but more remains the same. Perhaps it was inevitable that this, the saddest lesson, would be played out: loss of hope from such a high of euphoria, borne of the unprecedented collective consciousness that appeared to grab the masses from nowhere — those beautiful 18 days in which no mistakes were made.
Iraq Genocide
What a contrast to the catalogue of mistakes made in the days and months — indeed hours — that followed the departure of Mubarak. That is, as soon as the leaderless revolution needed leaders.
Many perhaps regret the indulgent celebrations held in Tahrir Square for weeks following 11 February, including handshakes and baby photo-ops with military soldiers who soon would be clearing the square by force, torturing artists with zeal, and subjecting the women of the revolution to virginity tests. And this was just the beginning. Some, too, might regret the lost time, and sense of buoyant surety, that led to the constitutional amendments defeat — the first and final (in that there was no revival) defeat of the revolution so soon after its supposed success.
It was in the wake of this defeat that calls gathered for a “second revolution”. The calls alone were acknowledgement of the failure of the first revolution. But even at this time most of the focus was on the “regime.” Few have been ready to understand that the problem is in the state. In this context, three incidents stand out on the sad path Egypt has taken in the last year; three incidents that perhaps cannot be outweighed by the positive changes that have survived, among which is a level of liberty of discourse unprecedented in Egypt’s modern history, prisoners of conscience of the revolution — first among which is Maikel Nabil — notwithstanding. These incidents increase in intensity and reveal something dark about the state that has survived as the former regime fell.
The first incident occurred on the first day of Ramadan. The plan to have a communal iftar in Tahrir Square was aborted as the Central Security Forces drove people out with sticks. To be sure, the stick generally is not an implement of fatal force. But there is something in the stick that is worse to the honest eye than the gun. Something representative about how the old regime thought of the people, and so gives its reappearance a particular significance. It was not 50 sticks, but 300. Some 300 sticks that had to be found, gathered from their place of storage, transported and handed out man by man, with instructions on what was coming next. It was on this day that the Muslim Brotherhood fell into line with the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces, for as a force they could not bring together Tahrir and Islam.
The second incident was the runaway vehicle near Maspero that literally drove over Egyptians, flattening them and killing them. Several vehicles were doing the same, but the APC that did so was several tons in weight and at no point in the video footage did it appear that it would stop. Rather, this was crowd control. The mask fell that night, 9 October. What was seen on the Corniche in the capital was really how the military regarded the Egyptian people: like sheep to be rounded up, and if necessary swept up. How heartbreaking now to see again the image of the woman who that night lost her fiancé, his face bludgeoned and distorted out of all proportion as she sat wailing, holding what the army had left of him.
The third instance is something akin to a war crime or crime against humanity: the open-air gassing of crowds of people on Mohamed Mahmoud Street. If Maspero was crowd control, Mohamed Mahmoud was pest control. It was quite a feat, indeed, to get the concentration of CS gas so high in open-air space that people died, asphyxiated. But this is what the military and the Central Security Forces clearly aimed at; testament to which is how they attacked field hospitals, killing even medical personnel there to help the helpless. It didn’t get worse than this, and heaven knows how deep and wide the economic catastrophe must be that Mubarak led the country into for the people as a whole not to simply refuse to participate in Egyptian public life after witnessing these horrid and impossible scenes.
And now here we are, a parliament full of suits. Of over 500, how many in there risked and lost? How many in there fought and won? Is it five, or is it 10? Is it one or two per cent of the whole? And so it is that when Dr Essam El-Erian, a decent man no doubt, arrives, it is the police who greet him, smiling, because we have carefully and successfully transitioned from one regime to a new regime in the making, without touching the foundations of the state itself, without touching its practices, its torture, its governmental rationality. How lost were the crowds and the intellectuals of the revolution, again in November, to call for the end of SCAF. The problem is not SCAF; it is the rationality of SCAF. The problem is not who, but how. The real issue is not taking power, but defanging power. What else, indeed, do rights really mean?
Over 1000 people died, and not for glorious nothingness. The so-called intellectuals of the secular left bear a heavy burden, if they could see it. In failing to put forward an economic plan for Egypt they allowed the people to turn against the revolution, tired and hungry.
In failing to form a solid and wide-ranging coalition they gave the revolution on a plate to the next best-organised political forces, including a newcomer that has nothing to do with the freedom of spirit, body and mind that was necessary to confront snipers and firebombs in January. And by failing to understand that a revolution must be led by its people, the people who constituted the revolution, not puppets of the like of ElBaradei, they sealed the fate of the revolution and the outcome of its last gasp, figuratively and literally: the zero political outcome that emerged from the heroic frontline resistance waged by football fans in Mohamed Mahmoud Street against the police that always brutalised them and means to continue doing so.
Same police force. Same sticks. Same rape by forced sodomy. Same tactics. Same governmental economic incompetence. Same one-party dominance. Same exceptional powers. Same bureaucracy. Same hall of mirrors. Same malaise. Same same same. The Arab Spring but an echo. Did we dream it?
Or perhaps something else can happen. Perhaps the people can start again to talk about freedom, and to practice freedom. Egyptians rose up for dignity. They refused torture. Real freedom is sovereignty of person; collective freedom is national sovereignty. Unless the rationality of the use of force is questioned it will not matter who exercises force, and it could even be a revolutionary. The idea of a social contract is that the people choose the cost of government; that is, the cost to their freedom of being governed. Political discourse in Egypt at present has accepted that replacing persons not structures and rationalities is the most important thing, and everyone in parliament is consciously or unconsciously complicit with this. But when the people called for the end of the nizam, the system, it meant more than persons; it was the violence of that system, and the costs of that government.
To SCAF: No more talk of foreign conspiracies. The Egyptian people are against the violence of the Egyptian state. They will oppose it regardless of what you pretend. Stop killing and beating the people.
To the people: It is time you took control of the mouthpiece. It is time for a completely free and cleansed media in Egypt. Otherwise you do not hear the truth of what happens; you hear what SCAF wants to you to hear, while people are fighting and dying still for your freedom.
To the politicians: Congratulate yourselves and pretend you are more respectable in parliament today than you were outside of it yesterday. But remember: the people are the greatest force in Egypt, and you cannot dictate — no more than Mubarak could — something as fundamental as the feeling of freedom.
Seif Abdul Shahid is a Cairo-based political analyst.
Pingback: buy dapoxetine pills()
Pingback: hydroxychloroquine 300 mg()
Pingback: hydroxychloroquine for psoriatic arthritis()
Pingback: plaquenil hydroxychloroquine malarial()
Pingback: hydroxychloroquine shortage 2020()
Pingback: hydroxychloroquine pills()
Pingback: ivermectil duration of action()
Pingback: ivermectai clav for uti()
Pingback: pastillas priligy()
Pingback: stromectol good for lymphatic filariasis()
Pingback: ospamox deltasone()
Pingback: ivermectin australia()
Pingback: stromectol for ear infection()
Pingback: stromectol 6mg for scabies()
Pingback: stromectol pi()
Pingback: ivermectin for pinworms in humans()
Pingback: plaquenil online no prescription()
Pingback: is ivermectin safe()
Pingback: ivermectin for herpes()
Pingback: ivermectin 12 mg()
Pingback: imidacloprid moxidectin generic()
Pingback: ivermectin dosage scabies()
Pingback: viagra 100 mg coupon()
Pingback: uk viagra prices()
Pingback: online prescription consultation pharmacy()
Pingback: tadalafil prescription canada()
Pingback: over the counter hydroxychloroquine for sale()
Pingback: can you buy viagra over the counter australia()
Pingback: stromectol sulfate for sale()
Pingback: tadalafil 50mg generic()
Pingback: how to buy viagra over the counter()
Pingback: bahis siteleri()
Pingback: A片()
Pingback: Beverly Bultron()
Pingback: What should I eat to recover sperm levitra canada?()
Pingback: What will happen if sperm come out daily levitra pill?()
Pingback: Medications and Sports Medicine - Optimizing Athletic Recovery stromectol 3mg?()
Pingback: Medications Revolutionize Treatment for Mental Health Disorders priligy 30mg?()
Pingback: Medications and Seasonal Allergies - Finding Relief from Pollen and More ivermectin for fleas?()
Pingback: Medications and Bladder Control - Regaining Urinary Continence vidalista?()
Pingback: Medications and Postpartum Wellness - Nurturing New Mothers lasix 40mg oral?()
Pingback: ivermectin side effects humans?()
Pingback: Medications and Irritable Bowel Syndrome - Finding Relief from Digestive Distress vidalista 60 mg centurion laboritories?()
Pingback: Medications and Skin Health - Enhancing Beauty and Well-being where can i buy dapoxetine?()
Pingback: stromectol 12mg online purchase?()
Pingback: Medications and Weight Management - Finding Balance for a Healthy Body kamagra uk?()
Pingback: Overcoming Health Challenges - Medication as a Key Solution can you keep kamagra in refridgerator?()
Pingback: Medications and Facial Rejuvenation - Enhancing Skin Vitality furosemide 100mg canada?()
Pingback: Why does the pull out method fail stromectol 3 mg pills?()
Pingback: Living with Chronic Pain - Strategies for Coping over the counter asthma medication?()
Pingback: Will my ED ever go away viagra low testosterone?()
Pingback: How long does a 7 day antibiotic stay in your system ivermectin otc?()
Pingback: How do you test a guy viagra walmart price()
Pingback: How do you know if someone is ignoring you on WhatsApp fildena 100 mg cheap()
Pingback: At what age a woman Cannot get pregnant viagra pills walmart()
Pingback: Does banana increase sperm count what is a viagra pill()
Pingback: pink viagra pills()
Pingback: Zithromax z-pak 250 mg()
Pingback: buy kamagra jelly next day delivery()
Pingback: kamagra or penegra()
Pingback: Can walking slim your legs??()
Pingback: What is it called when girls wake up wet??()
Pingback: medicamento priligy 30 mg - What happens if you take sildenafil everyday?()
Pingback: buy priligy singapore()
Pingback: avanafil and dapoxetine for sale()
Pingback: Zithromax class()
Pingback: how to get a prescription for viagra()
Pingback: generic clomid()
Pingback: kamagra for woman()
Pingback: Azithromycine()
Pingback: vidalista 60 reddit()
Pingback: purchase Cenforce online()
Pingback: canada levitra()
Pingback: tadalista 20mg()
Pingback: revatio tablet uses()
Pingback: vilitra()
Pingback: proair hfa uses()
Pingback: Can antibiotics be used for urinary tract infections (UTIs) in pregnancy hydroxychloroquine 200 mg tablet?()
Pingback: walmart viagra price()
Pingback: prix priligy 30 mg()
Pingback: dapoxetine 90 mg reviews()
Pingback: cenforce 500mg()
Pingback: generic plaquenil()
Pingback: sildenafil pill()
Pingback: cheap Cenforce 100mg()
Pingback: best price on levitra()
Pingback: hydroxychloroquine sulfate 200mg()
Pingback: vidalista active ingredient()
Pingback: cenforce 200mg reddit()
Pingback: tadalafil vidalista 20mg()
Pingback: priligy 30mg()
Pingback: vidalista 20 tadalafil tablets()
Pingback: clomid and testosterone()
Pingback: where to buy fildena 100()
Pingback: clomid for pcos()
Pingback: buy clomid online()
Pingback: generic form of clomid()
Pingback: Buy clomid Online()
Pingback: buy cheap online dapoxetine from india()
Pingback: buy poxet()
Pingback: kamagra oral jelly buy online india()
Pingback: vidalista black 80()
Pingback: centurion laboratories vidalista 40()
Pingback: vidalista professional 20 review()
Pingback: advair diskus 250 50()
Pingback: vidalista smart farming()
Pingback: advairdiskus()
Pingback: cenforce 200mg price()
Pingback: Sildenafil 100mg()
Pingback: oral ivermectin for rosacea()
Pingback: Cenforce 150 mg for sale()
Pingback: fildena 100 mg price()
Pingback: cenforce professional 100()
Pingback: albuterol sulfate()
Pingback: cenforce 200 werkt niet()
Pingback: tadalafil without subscription()
Pingback: cenforce professional 100()
Pingback: vidalista 20mg()
Pingback: cenforce 100 per nachnahme()
Pingback: furosemide 20mg tab()
Pingback: super force tablet()
Pingback: where to buy kamagra()
Pingback: Sildenafil mech()
Pingback: cenforce 200 koupit()
Pingback: seretide 25 250()
Pingback: fildena 150()
Pingback: vidalista()
Pingback: cenforce 200 gevaarlijk()
Pingback: kamagra 100 chewable()
Pingback: dapoxetine and sildenafil tablets india()
Pingback: buspar pill()
Pingback: vidalista 60 mg for sale()
Pingback: nubeta 2.5()
Pingback: seretide diskus 500()
Pingback: vermact 12 mg tablet uses()
Pingback: iverheal12()
Pingback: kamagra pharmacy malaysia()
Pingback: kamagra 50 mg tablet()
Pingback: iverkind 12mg()
Pingback: ivermectol tablet()
Pingback: imrotab 6()
Pingback: vidalista 60 usa()
Pingback: buy levitra()
Pingback: tadalista 5 mg()
Pingback: buy sildenafil 100mg sale()
Pingback: fildena super active 150mg()
Pingback: purchase fildena online cheap()
Pingback: safe vidalista dosage()
Pingback: vidalista()
Pingback: seroflo 250 india()
Pingback: buy dapoxetine online()
Pingback: vidalista 10 centurion laboratories()
Pingback: priligy for sale()
Pingback: dapoxetine hydrochloride tablet()
Pingback: cenforce 100 price()
Pingback: buy sildenafil 100mg for sale()
Pingback: the best viagra pills()
Pingback: cenforce 25()
Pingback: cheaper alternative to rybelsus()
Pingback: can i take rybelsus every other day()
Pingback: obat motilium 10 mg()
Pingback: buy vardenafil()
Pingback: asthalin inhaler frequency()
Pingback: purple fildena 100 mg tablets()
Pingback: buy levitra online()
Pingback: amoxicillin price()